UPSC Exams
Latest Update
UP Police Head Operator Result 2025 UPSSSC Junior Assistant Admit Card 2025 Fastag Annual Pass 2025 UGC NET Answer Key June 2025 UGC NET Exam Analysis 2025 UGC NET Question Paper 2025 AP LAWCET Result 2025 UGC NET City Slip 2025 UPSC DAF 1 2025 Rajasthan PTET Answer Key 2025 UPSC Prelims Result 2025 UPSC IFS Result 2025 8th Pay Commission Salary Hike News UPSC 2024 Prelims Answer Key UPSC 2026 Calendar UPSC Admit Card 2025 UPSC Prelims Result Date 2025 UPSC Prelims Answer Key 2025 UPSC Prelims 2025 Expected Cut Off UPSC Prelims Exam Analysis 2025 UPSC Final Result 2025 UPSC Topper Shakti Dubey UPSC Application Rejected List 2025 UPSC Application Date Re-Extended UPSC Interview Date 2024 UPSC Notification 2025 UPSC Admit Card 2025 for Prelims UPSC CSE Prelims 2025 Question Paper UPSC IFS Notification 2025 Indian Navy MR Result 2025 Indian Navy SSR Result 2025
Coaching
UPSC Current Affairs
Syllabus
UPSC Notes
Previous Year Papers
UPSC Mains Previous Year Question Papers Last 25 Years UPSC Prelims Question Papers Last 10 Years UPSC Question Papers UPSC CSE Prelims 2025 Question Paper UPSC Mains 2024 Model Answers UPSC 2024 Question Papers UPSC 2023 Question Papers UPSC 2022 Question Papers UPSC 2021 Question Papers UPSC 2020 Question Papers UPSC 2019 Question Papers UPSC 2018 Question Papers UPSC 2017 Question Papers UPSC 2016 Question Papers UPSC 2015 Question Papers UPSC 2014 Question Papers UPSC CSAT Question Papers UPSC IFS Previous Year Paper UPSC Assistant Labour Commissioner Previous Question Year Papers UPSC Combined Geo Scientist Previous Year Paper UPSC APFC Previous Year Question Papers UPSC CMS Previous Year Question Paper UPSC EPFO Previous Year Paper UPSC Air Safety Officer Previous Year Papers UPSC SO Steno Previous Year Paper UPSC IES ISS Previous Year Question Papers
Mock Tests
UPSC Editorial
Bilateral Ties
Albania India Relations India Algeria Relations Andorra India Relations India Angola Relations India Antigua Barbuda Relations India Argentina Relations Austria India Relations India Azerbaijan Relations Bahamas India Relations India Bahrain Relations Barbados India Relations India Belarus Relations Belgium India Relations Belize India Relations Benin India Relations Bolivia India Relations India Bosnia Herzegovina Relations India Botswana Relations Brazil India Relations Brunei India Relations Bulgaria India Relations Burundi India Relations Cabo Verde India Relations India Cambodia Relations India Cameroon Relations Canada India Relations India Cayman Islands Relations India Central African Republic Relations India Chad Relations Chile India Relations India Colombia Relations India Comoros Relations India Democratic Republic Of The Congo Relations India Republic Of The Congo Relations India Cook Islands Relations India Costa Rica Relations India Ivory Coast Relations India Croatia Relations India Cyprus Relations India Czech Republic Relations India Djibouti Relations India Dominica Relations India Dominican Republic Relations India Ecuador Relations India El Salvador Relations India Equatorial Guinea Relations India Eritrea Relations Estonia India Relations India Ethiopia Relations India Fiji Relations India Finland Relations India Gabon Relations India Gambia Relations India Georgia Relations Germany India Relations India Ghana Relations India Greece Relations India Grenada Relations India Guatemala Relations India Guinea Relations India Guinea Bissau Relations India Guyana Relations India Haiti Relations India Holy See Relations India Honduras Relations India Hong Kong Relations India Hungary Relations India Iceland Relations India Indonesia Relations India Iran Relations India Iraq Relations India Ireland Relations India Jamaica Relations India Kazakhstan Relations India Kenya Relations India Kingdom Of Eswatini Relations India Kiribati Relations India Kuwait Relations India Kyrgyzstan Relations India Laos Relations Latvia India Relations India Lebanon Relations India Lesotho Relations India Liberia Relations Libya India Relations Liechtenstein India Relations India Lithuania Relations India Luxembourg Relations India Macao Relations Madagascar India Relations India Malawi Relations India Mali Relations India Malta Relations India Marshall Islands Relations India Mauritania Relations India Micronesia Relations India Moldova Relations Monaco India Relations India Montenegro Relations India Montserrat Relations India Morocco Relations Mozambique India Relations India Namibia Relations India Nauru Relations Netherlands India Relations India Nicaragua Relations India Niger Relations India Nigeria Relations India Niue Relations India North Macedonia Relations Norway India Relations India Palau Relations India Panama Relations India Papua New Guinea Relations India Paraguay Relations Peru India Relations India Philippines Relations Qatar India Relations India Romania Relations Rwanda India Relations India Saint Kitts And Nevis Relations India Saint Lucia Relations India Saint Vincent And Grenadines Relations India Samoa Relations India Sao Tome And Principe Relations Saudi Arabia India Relations India Senegal Relations Serbia India Relations India Sierra Leone Relations India Singapore Relations India Slovak Republic Relations India Slovenia Relations India Solomon Islands Relations Somalia India Relations India South Sudan Relations India Spain Relations India Sudan Relations Suriname India Relations India Sweden Relations India Syria Relations India Tajikistan Relations Tanzania India Relations India Togo Relations India Tonga Islands Relations India Trinidad And Tobago Relations India Tunisia Relations India Turkmenistan Relations India Turks And Caicos Islands Relations India Tuvalu Relations India Uganda Relations India Ukraine Relations India Uae Relations India Uruguay Relations India Uzbekistan Relations India Vanuatu Relations India Venezuela Relations India British Virgin Islands Relations Yemen India Relations India Zambia Relations India Zimbabwe Relations
Books
Government Schemes
Production Linked Incentive Scheme Integrated Processing Development Scheme Rodtep Scheme Amended Technology Upgradation Fund Scheme Saathi Scheme Uday Scheme Hriday Scheme Samagra Shiksha Scheme India Nishta Scheme Stand Up India Scheme Sahakar Mitra Scheme Mdms Mid Day Meal Scheme Integrated Child Protection Scheme Vatsalya Scheme Operation Green Scheme Nai Roshni Scheme Nutrient Based Subsidy Scheme Kalia Scheme Ayushman Sahakar Scheme Nirvik Scheme Fame India Scheme Kusum Scheme Pm Svanidhi Scheme Pmvvy Scheme Pm Aasha Scheme Pradhan Mantri Mahila Shakti Kendra Scheme Pradhan Mantri Lpg Panjayat Scheme Mplads Scheme Svamitva Scheme Pat Scheme Udan Scheme Ek Bharat Shresth Bharat Scheme National Pension Scheme Ujala Scheme Operation Greens Scheme Gold Monetisation Scheme Family Planning Insurance Scheme Target Olympic Podium Scheme
Topics
NASA Space Missions
NASA Mercury-Redstone 3 (Freedom 7) Mission NASA Mercury-Redstone 4 (Liberty Bell 7) Mission NASA Mercury-Atlas 6 (Friendship 7) Mission NASA Mercury-Atlas 7 (Aurora 7) Mission NASA Mercury-Atlas 8 (Sigma 7) Mission NASA Mercury-Atlas 9 (Faith 7) Mission NASA Gemini 3 Mission NASA Gemini 4 Mission NASA Gemini 5 Mission NASA Gemini 7 Mission NASA Gemini 8 Mission NASA Gemini 9 Mission NASA Gemini 10 Mission NASA Gemini 11 Mission NASA Gemini 12 Mission NASA Apollo 1 (AS‑204) Mission NASA Apollo 7 Mission NASA Apollo 8 Mission NASA Apollo 9 Mission NASA Apollo 10 Mission NASA Apollo 11 Mission NASA Apollo 12 Mission NASA Apollo 13 Mission NASA Apollo 14 Mission NASA Apollo 15 Mission NASA Apollo 16 Mission NASA Apollo 17 Mission NASA Skylab Orbital Workshop Mission NASA Skylab 2 Mission NASA Skylab 3 Mission NASA Skylab 4 Mission NASA Apollo–Soyuz Test Project Mission NASA STS‑1 Columbia Mission NASA STS‑3 Columbia Mission NASA STS‑7 Challenger Mission NASA STS‑8 Challenger Mission NASA STS‑41B Challenger Mission NASA STS‑41G Discovery (1st female EVA) Mission NASA STS‑51L Challenger (accident) Mission NASA STS‑26 Discovery (Return‑to‑Flight) Mission NASA STS‑31 Discovery (Hubble Launch) Mission NASA STS‑49 Endeavour (first capture EVA) Mission NASA STS‑61 Endeavour (Hubble Servicing 1) Mission NASA STS‑73 Columbia (microgravity) Mission NASA STS‑95 Discovery (John Glenn returns) Mission NASA STS‑107 Columbia (accident) Mission NASA STS‑114 Discovery (RTF‑2) Mission NASA STS‑120 Discovery (Node 2) Mission NASA STS‑125 Atlantis (Final Hubble Service) Mission NASA STS‑132 Atlantis Mission NASA STS‑135 Atlantis (Final Shuttle flight) Mission NASA Artemis I (Orion/ SLS‑1) Mission NASA Artemis II (Planned) Mission NASA Artemis III (Planned lunar landing) Mission NASA Mariner 4 Mission NASA Mariner 6 Mission NASA Mariner 7 Mission NASA Mariner 9 Mission NASA Viking 1 Orbiter/Lander Mission NASA Viking 2 Orbiter/Lander Mission NASA Mars Pathfinder & Sojourner Mission NASA Mars Global Surveyor Mission NASA 2001 Mars Odyssey Mission NASA Mars Exploration Rover – Spirit Mission NASA Mars Exploration Rover – Opportunity Mission NASA Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter Mission NASA Phoenix Mars Lander Mission NASA InSight Mars Lander Mission NASA Mars 2020 (Perseverance & Ingenuity) Mission NASA Mars Sample Return – SRL (planned) Mission NASA Pioneer 10 Mission NASA Pioneer 11 Mission NASA Voyager 1 Mission NASA Voyager 2 Mission NASA Galileo Jupiter Orbiter/Probe Mission NASA Cassini–Huygens Mission NASA New Horizons (Pluto & KBO) Mission NASA Juno Mission NASA Europa Clipper (planned) Mission NASA Parker Solar Probe Mission NASA Solar Orbiter (ESA/NASA) Mission NASA Surveyor 1 Mission NASA Lunar Orbiter 1 Mission NASA Lunar Prospector Mission NASA LCROSS Mission NASA LADEE Mission NASA Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO) Mission NASA CAPSTONE Mission NASA VIPER Rover (planned) Mission NASA NEAR Shoemaker Mission NASA Deep Space 1 Mission NASA Stardust Mission NASA Genesis Mission NASA Deep Impact Mission NASA Dawn (Vesta/Ceres) Mission NASA OSIRIS‑REx Mission NASA Lucy Mission NASA DART Mission NASA Landsat‑1 (ERTS‑1) Mission NASA Landsat‑5 Mission NASA Landsat‑9 Mission NASA Terra Mission NASA Aqua Mission NASA Aura Mission NASA Suomi NPP Mission NASA Sentinel‑6 Michael Freilich Mission NASA ICESat‑2 Mission NASA GRACE‑FO Mission NASA SMAP Mission NASA GPM Core Observatory Mission NASA CALIPSO Mission NASA CloudSat Mission NASA NISAR (NASA‑ISRO) Mission NASA Explorer 1 Mission NASA COBE Mission NASA Compton Gamma Ray Observatory Mission NASA Hubble Space Telescope Mission NASA Chandra X‑ray Observatory Mission NASA Spitzer Space Telescope Mission NASA WISE Mission NASA Kepler Mission NASA TESS Mission NASA Fermi Gamma‑ray Space Telescope Mission NASA NICER Mission NASA IXPE Mission NASA Roman Space Telescope (planned) Mission NASA NuSTAR Mission NASA GALEX Mission NASA Swift Mission NASA SOHO (ESA/NASA) Mission NASA Cluster II (ESA/NASA) Mission NASA TIMED Mission NASA STEREO‑A/B Mission NASA MMS Mission NASA IRIS Mission NASA Solar Dynamics Observatory Mission NASA X‑37B OTV‑1 (USAF/NASA liaison) Mission NASA X‑59 QueSST Mission NASA Mars Helicopter Ingenuity Mission NASA Valkyrie R5 Robot Mission NASA Low‑Boom Flight Demo Mission NASA CRS‑1 Dragon Mission NASA CRS‑1 Cygnus Mission NASA Crew Dragon Demo‑2 Mission NASA Starliner OFT‑2 Mission NASA STS-2 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-4 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-5 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-6 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-41C (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-41D (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-51A (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-61C (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-26 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-27 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-29 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-30 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-32 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-34 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-38 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-45 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-60 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-70 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-71 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-73 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-88 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-92 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-97 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-99 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-100 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-104 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-106 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-110 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-112 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-115 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-116 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-117 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-118 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-120 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-122 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-123 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-126 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA STS-130 (Shuttle flight) Mission NASA Vanguard 1 Mission NASA Transit 1B Mission NASA Echo 1 Mission NASA Telstar 1 Mission NASA Syncom 3 Mission NASA ATS‑6 Mission NASA Skynet Mission NASA Nimbus‑1 Mission NASA Nimbus‑7 Mission NASA ERS-1 Mission NASA SeaSat Mission NASA QuikSCAT Mission NASA Jason‑1 Mission NASA Jason‑3 Mission NASA ICESat Mission NASA Earth Observing‑1 Mission NASA Orbiting Carbon Observatory‑2 Mission NASA CYGNSS Mission NASA PACE Mission NASA TRMM Mission NASA Terrestrial Planet Finder (cxl) Mission NASA Laser Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) Mission NASA Explorer 33 Mission NASA Voyager Interstellar Mission Mission NASA Helios‑A Mission NASA Helios‑B Mission NASA ISEE‑3 (ICE) Mission NASA ACE Mission NASA DSCOVR Mission NASA IBEX Mission NASA Solar Orbiter Heliospheric Imager Mission NASA SAGE‑III ISS Mission NASA SPACE Telescope Imaging Spectrograph Mission NASA ARIEL (ESA/NASA) Mission NASA OSAM‑1 (Restore‑L) Mission NASA Dragonfly (Titan rotorcraft) Mission NASA VERITAS (Venus orbiter) Mission NASA DAVINCI (Venus probe) Mission NASA SPHEREx Mission NASA MAGGIE (Mars Geophysical) Mission NASA CLPS – Peregrine Mission NASA CLPS – VIPER Delivery Mission NASA CAPSTONE Mission NASA Gateway (HALO / PPE) Mission NASA Mars Telecommunication Orbiter (cxl) Mission NASA Mars Polar Lander (MPL) Mission NASA Mars Climate Orbiter Mission NASA Pathfinder Mission Mission NASA SLS Block 1B (Exploration Upper Stage) Mission NASA Orion Crew Module Mission NASA Commercial LEO Destinations – Axiom Station Mission NASA ISS Expedition 1 Mission NASA ISS Expedition 70 Mission NASA CRS‑11 (Dragon) Mission NASA CRS‑21 (Dragon 2) Mission NASA Snoopy CubeSat Mission

Karnataka High Court Strikes Down Central Green Energy Rules- UPSC Editorial

Last Updated on Jan 24, 2025
Download As PDF
IMPORTANT LINKS

Karnataka High Court recently scrapped some of the significant green energy rules framed by the central government. The court has held that the central government does not have the authority under the Electricity Act to create such rules. Rather than this, it focuses on the fact that it is those State Commissions that are entrusted with regulation of "open access" issues in renewable energy areas. Thus, this judgment lays emphasis on jurisdiction and the defined roles of different regulatory authorities under the Electricity Act.

For the UPSC aspirants, this topic is essential because it touches upon federalism, judicial review, and energy policies, all of which fall within the purview of the General Studies papers. This knowledge helps them enhance their understanding about the jurisdictional limits of the central and state governments and the role of judiciary in maintaining those boundaries.

Analysis based on 

Editorial Why the Karnataka High Court struck down green energy rules by centre, state

 

published in The Indian Express on January 23rd, 2025

Topics for UPSC Prelims

Renewable Energy Policies, Federal Structure in India

Topics for UPSC Mains

Judiciary and Regulatory Framework, Federalism and Jurisdictional Roles

Why in News?

 A key case is that Karnataka High Court had struck down central green energy rules. It makes its implications for the concept of federalism and judicial review, by showing jurisdictional boundary between central government and state governments in Electricity Act, 2003, under the purview of regulatory power regarding renewable energy.Such topics are seen very often in UPSC exams through questions on separation of powers, administrative law, and energy policies, which makes it really important for an aspirant to know this case.

Read article on National Power Portal!

UPSC Beginners Program

Get UPSC Beginners Program SuperCoaching @ just

₹50000

Claim for free

Karnataka High Court Decision

The Karnataka High Court recently quashed central government norms on green energy. These were framed under the Electricity (Promoting Renewable Energy Through Green Energy Open Access) Rules, 2022. The court held that the central government does not have jurisdiction to frame such rules under the Electricity Act as only the State Commissions have such jurisdiction.

Striking Down of Rules

The Karnataka High Court struck down the central government’s Electricity (Promoting Renewable Energy Through Green Energy Open Access) Rules, 2022. The court ruled that the central government overstepped its authority as these rules fall within the jurisdiction of state regulatory bodies under the Electricity Act, 2003.

Jurisdictional Limitations

The judgment also emphasized that the powers of the central government under the Electricity Act, 2003 do not extend to regulation of "open access" in renewable energy markets. This has underlined the need to strictly adhere to statutory boundaries set by the Act.

Decentralization of Regulatory Power

Companies opposed state regulations through central law. Justice N S Sanjay Gowda held in favor of decentralizing the regulatory power to state commissions while strictly adhering to the statutory provisions and keeping proper jurisdictional boundaries.

Read article on AIR Spotlight – Discussion with the Union Minister for Power!

Regulatory Authority

It underscored the role of State Commissions in controlling "open access" in renewable energy. It has observed that the Electricity Act, 2003, vests exclusive powers of regulation in these commissions. This judgment reiterates that the central government cannot encroach upon areas especially allocated to state authorities, keeping jurisdictional demarcations forth.

Exclusive State Regulation

The Karnataka High Court highlighted that State Commissions have exclusive powers to regulate "open access" generation, transmission, and supply of electricity under the Electricity Act, 2003 including renewable energy regulations.

Prevention of Central Overreach

This ruling does not allow the center to enter the jurisdiction of the state's regulatory bodies; instead, it safeguards the powers of the state authority over local energy markets and related regulatory procedures. 

Legal Implications 

The order of the court establishes the principle that the regulation over renewable energy open access shall only be governed by the state level commissions to have an unambiguous and compliant regime of regulation. 

Read article on Bharat Gaurav Scheme!

Role of State Commissions

As noted by State Commissions Justice Gowda, management of renewable energy generation that includes grid connectivity and energy sale is one of the statutory functions under the control of State Commissions.Decentralization plays an important role in regulating the energy market to make sure state bodies retain their regulatory power as expected in the law.

Regulation under Section 86(1)(e)

Justice Gowda pointed out that Section 86(1)(e) of the Electricity Act places upon the State Commissions the tasks of regulating the generation, transmission of renewable energy and ensuring grid connectivity within their territories.

State-Specific Regulation

 State Commissions govern the open market procurement of green energy to ensure the satisfaction of specific state-specific requirements by the body concerned. 

Decentralized Regulation

This ruling emphasizes decentralizing renewable energy regulation to state authorities, allowing state-specific strategies to be implemented by localized regulatory bodies without central government intervention.

Read article on Urban Jyoti Abhiyaan (URJA)!

Past Judgments

The court cited previous judgments of the Supreme Court to justify its decision. In Naresh Chandra Agrawal v The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India, the SC held that rule-making bodies should not overstep the limits provided by statute. Such precedents strengthen the argument for the observance of statutory limits and avoid the exercise of regulatory powers beyond the limits prescribed.

Observance of Statutory Limits 

The Karnataka High Court relied upon Supreme Court order Naresh Chandra Agrawal v. The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India whereby it stated that rule making body must confine itself within limits prescribed to the rule-making powers by enabling statue.

State Commission Autonomy

Autonomy The Supreme Court case in Kerala State Electricity Board v Jhabua Power Limited reiterated the position that the state regulatory commissions are governed by, but not limited by, directives from the central or state authority..

Prevention of Overreach

Such earlier judgments provide an emphasis that delegated powers cannot take precedence over statutory authority given to particular organizations; hence, neither the central government nor its constituent agencies can reach out to exceed defined boundaries in law. 

Read article on Deen Dayal Upadhyaya Gram Jyoti Yojana!

Consequences for Federalism 

This judgment brings a lot of implications to the Indian system of federalism. The division of power between central and state governments especially with regard to energy is confirmed in this judgment. UPSC aspirants will find it interesting to note that jurisdictional clarity and the role of the judiciary in maintaining the balance of power have been recurrent issues in civil services exams

Separation of Powers

The judgment of the court is based on federalism principles, as it strengthens the separation of powers between the central and state governments, especially in the regulation of renewable energy markets.

Balanced Power Distribution

This judgment provides both levels of government to operate under constitutionally defined spheres, maintain the balanced distribution of powers of regulations, and therefore avert overreaching the center into state jurisdiction.

Understanding Federal Structure

The case would explain to UPSC aspirants why it is important to have a federal understanding in governing India and how judicial reviews protect the autonomy and authority of state governments.

Read article on Pradhan Mantri Sahaj Bijli Har Ghar Yojana (Saubhagya)!

Way Forward

It needs ensuring that the state-level regulatory commissions are adequately empowered with resources and autonomy, promoting consultation among central and state governments on policy-making for coherent frameworks, and amending the Electricity Act 2003, which contains jurisdictional roles in unambiguous terms. Moreover, there is a need for state bodies to have capacity building on the regulation of renewable energy with improvement in their skill. Continuous stakeholder engagement involving dialogue among central authorities, state commissions, industry participants, and the judiciary will address concerns and bring about alignment. This will result in balanced governance, effective regulation, and sustainable development in the renewable energy sector. 

Testbook is one of the leading Edu-tech platforms. You can prepare for SSC, banking, UPSC, Railway and various other exams with the help of our updated syllabus and course materials. You can also track your progress with daily quizzes, mock tests, question banks, and current affairs. Download the Testbook App now!

UPSC Practice Questions
  1. What implications does the Karnataka High Court decision to strike down the Central Green Energy Rules have on the federal structure of India? How does this affect the state and central government balance of power?
  2. Discuss the role of the judiciary in resolving conflicts arising from overlapping jurisdictions between central and state laws in India. Use the example of the Karnataka High Court verdict on Green Energy Rules to explain your answer.
  3. Discuss the jurisdictional conflict between central and state authorities in the renewable energy sector in India, which has challenged the regulatory bodies. Recommend a more coherent and integrated regulatory framework.

Report An Error