This question consists of a statement and two conclusions numbered i and ii. You have to decide which of the given conclusions is logical in respect of the statements assuming that the statements are true.

Statement: Everyone who lives in Madrid must keep a dog. John lives in Madrid.

Conclusions:

i). John does not have a dog.

ii). One who does not live in Madrid will not have a dog.

Choose the most appropriate one from the following options:

A. Only conclusion i is logical

B. Only conclusion ii is logical

C. Either conclusion i or ii is logical

D. Neither conclusion i nor ii is logical

E. Both conclusions i and ii are logical.

This question was previously asked in
RPF SI (2018) Official Paper (Held On: 24 Dec, 2018 Shift 1)
View all RPF SI Papers >
  1. A
  2. E
  3. B
  4. D

Answer (Detailed Solution Below)

Option 4 : D
Free
RPF SI Full Mock Test
2.3 Lakh Users
120 Questions 120 Marks 90 Mins

Detailed Solution

Download Solution PDF

Given,

Statement:

Everyone who lives in Madrid must keep a dog. John lives in Madrid.

Conclusions:

I. John does not have a dog - False (Because, the statement specifies that everyone who lives in Madrid must keep a dog, and since John lives in Madrid, he must have a dog).

II. One who does not live in Madrid will not have a dog - False (Because, the statement does not provide information about people who do not live in Madrid and whether they can or cannot have a dog).

So, neither conclusion I nor II follows.

Hence, the correct answer is "Option 4".

Latest RPF SI Updates

Last updated on Jun 7, 2025

-> RPF SI Physical Test Admit Card 2025 has been released on the official website. The PMT and PST is scheduled from 22nd June 2025 to 2nd July 2025. 

-> This Dates are for the previous cycle of RPF SI Recruitment.

-> Indian Ministry of Railways will release the RPF Recruitment 2025 notification for the post of Sub-Inspector (SI).

-> The vacancies and application dates will be announced for the RPF Recruitment 2025 on the official website. Also, RRB ALP 2025 Notification was released. 

-> The selection process includes CBT, PET & PMT, and Document Verification. Candidates need to pass all the stages to get selected in the RPF SI Recruitment 2025. 

-> Prepare for the exam with RPF SI Previous Year Papers and boost your score in the examination. 

More Statements and Conclusions Questions

Get Free Access Now
Hot Links: teen patti 100 bonus teen patti download apk teen patti master king