qImage67935a3b66dea91f6d4c7b9d

The line marked as X is the closed loop response of: 

This question was previously asked in
BHEL Engineer Trainee Electrical 23 Aug 2023 Official Paper
View all BHEL Engineer Trainee Papers >
  1. a P controller 
  2. a PD controller 
  3. a PI controller 
  4. an I controller  

Answer (Detailed Solution Below)

Option 3 : a PI controller 
Free
BHEL Engineer Trainee Fluid Mechanics Mock Test
1.4 K Users
20 Questions 20 Marks 15 Mins

Detailed Solution

Download Solution PDF

Explanation:

Single Acting Steam Engine

Definition: A single acting steam engine is a type of steam engine where the steam acts on only one side of the piston during its operation, producing one working stroke per revolution of the crankshaft. This configuration contrasts with double-acting steam engines, where the steam alternately acts on both sides of the piston.

Working Principle: In a single acting steam engine, steam is introduced into the cylinder on one side of the piston. The pressure of the steam pushes the piston, converting thermal energy into mechanical work. After the steam has expanded, it is exhausted, and the piston is returned to its original position by a flywheel or another mechanism, ready for the next cycle.

Advantages:

  • Simplicity in design and construction, making it easier to manufacture and maintain.
  • Less mechanical complexity compared to double-acting engines, resulting in fewer parts and potential points of failure.

Disadvantages:

  • Lower efficiency as only one side of the piston is used for performing work.
  • Requires a more substantial flywheel to maintain smooth operation due to the intermittent power delivery.

Applications: Single acting steam engines are commonly used in smaller applications where simplicity and cost are critical factors, such as in some types of pumps and small locomotives.

Correct Option Analysis:

The correct option is:

Option 3: a PI controller

This option correctly describes the closed loop response of a PI controller. A Proportional-Integral (PI) controller is used in control systems to improve the performance of the system by considering both the present and the past errors. The Proportional (P) part addresses the current error, while the Integral (I) part addresses the accumulation of past errors, which helps eliminate the steady-state error.

In the given context, the closed loop response marked as X is likely indicative of the characteristics of a PI controller, such as improved steady-state performance and reduced oscillations compared to other types of controllers.

Additional Information

To further understand the analysis, let’s evaluate the other options:

Option 1: a P controller

A Proportional (P) controller responds to the current error but does not consider the accumulation of past errors. This often results in a faster response but can leave a steady-state error. The closed loop response of a P controller would typically be more oscillatory and less stable compared to a PI controller.

Option 2: a PD controller

A Proportional-Derivative (PD) controller uses the present error and the rate of change of the error (derivative). This can provide a faster response and reduce overshoot, but it does not eliminate the steady-state error as effectively as a PI controller. The closed loop response of a PD controller would show quicker damping but would not address steady-state errors as well as a PI controller.

Option 4: an I controller

An Integral (I) controller considers the accumulation of past errors, which helps eliminate steady-state errors but can lead to slower responses and potential instability if not properly tuned. The closed loop response of an I controller would typically be slower and more prone to oscillations.

Conclusion:

Understanding the different types of controllers and their impact on the closed loop response is crucial in control systems. The PI controller combines the advantages of both Proportional and Integral actions, leading to improved steady-state performance and stability. This makes it suitable for a wide range of applications where both quick response and minimal steady-state error are desired.

Latest BHEL Engineer Trainee Updates

Last updated on Jul 8, 2025

-> The BHEL Cut Off 2025 has been uploaded on July 8, 2025 at the official website 

-> BHEL Engineer Trainee result has been released on July 8. 

-> BHEL Engineer Trainee answer key 2025 has been released at the official website. 

-> The BHEL Engineer Trainee Admit Card 2025 has been released on the official website.

->The BHEL Engineer Trainee Exam 2025 will be conducted on April 11th, 12th and 13th, 2025

-> BHEL Engineer Trainee 2025 Notification has been released on the official website.

-> A total of 150 Vacancies have been announced for various disciplines of Engineering like Mechanical, Electrical, Civil, etc.

-> Interested and eligible candidates can apply from 1st February 2025 to 28th February 2025.

-> The authorities has also released the BHEL Engineer Trainee Pattern 

-> The BHEL Engineer Trainee Selection Process is divided into two stages namely Written Test and Interview.

-> The selected candidates for the Engineer Trainee post will get a salary range between Rs. 60,000 - Rs. 1,80,000.

Get Free Access Now
Hot Links: teen patti star teen patti wealth teen patti live teen patti joy mod apk teen patti bodhi